Marshmallow Monster Eyeballs

Eyeballs. There is something that I find squeamish about them whether it’s watching someone away get a drill through their eye in a horror movie (this is actually turning my stomach writing this) or years ago when an eye procedure was booked in at work I would make myself scarce so I wouldn’t have to go into theatre and someone else would have to assist instead. Even getting my make up applied once I freaked out as they approached me with a mascara wand and told me to keep my eyes open. Just no! I can do it myself, thank you!!

These eyeballs however I do like, these Marshmallow Monster Eyeballs are a Halloween version of Top Hats that were quite common at children’s parties and cake sales when I was younger, do you still get these or are they now regarded “retro” like cheese and pineapple hedgehogs?


Halloween Sweet Treats
Halloween Sweet Treats

These Monster Eyeballs are really easy to make and taste pretty good too. Ideal sweet treats for a Halloween party or to munch on while watching a scary film (without the eye drill scene).


Marshmallow Monster Eyeballs


What you need:

Mini cupcake cases (or cake pop sticks if you prefer)
White chocolate (Go for a good quality one rather than cheap as it tastes less sickly, I used Green & Black’s)
Smarties or chocolate M&Ms
Red & black edible ink pens

How to make:

Draw red lines on the marshmallow using the edible ink pen to give your “eye” a bloodshot look, also draw a dot on the Smarties/M&Ms using the black edible ink pen to give pupils to the “iris”
Break up your chocolate into a bowl and melt it over a hot pan or blast it in the microwave
Once the chocolate has melted, put a teaspoon of the chocolate into the bottom of the cupcake case and then place the marshmallow inside.
Put a drop of melted chocolate on the top of the marshmallow and stick on one of the Smarties/M&Ms
Place in a fridge until chocolate hardens

If you try out this recipe or anything else from my blog, I’d really love to hear any feedback!

If you are looking for other sweet treat recipes:

Mini Pumpkin Pies

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

* Checkbox GDPR is required


I agree